The sticker price of a pallet tells only part of the story. When you factor in handling, disposal, and how long a pallet lasts, recycled pallets are often the better value. Here is how to compare.
Beyond the Sticker Price
When comparing new and recycled pallets, most buyers focus on the per-unit purchase price. Recycled pallets usually cost less than new pallets of the same size, but the true comparison goes beyond the invoice. Pallet Colorado does not publish prices; pricing comes by quote from partner suppliers.
Total cost of ownership includes the purchase price plus transportation, storage, handling, damage, and disposal over the life of the pallet.
For companies that go through a lot of pallets, understanding the full cost leads to better buying decisions.
The Price of New Pallets
New pallet prices are driven largely by lumber costs, which can swing with housing demand, sawmill capacity, weather, and other market forces.
Manufacturing adds sawing, drying in many cases, hauling lumber to the pallet plant, cutting, and assembly. Labor and freight costs flow through to the buyer.
When demand is high, new pallets can take longer to get, and rushing an order or sourcing from farther away can raise the effective cost.
The Price of Recycled Pallets
Recycled pallet pricing is often less tied to lumber markets because the main inputs are collection, sorting, repair labor, replacement boards, and freight rather than new lumber.
Grade affects price. Grade A recycled pallets cost more than Grade B but usually less than new. Grade B pallets, which are functional with cosmetic wear, are usually the most economical option where appearance does not matter.
Volume and consistency matter. Describe your expected volume in your quote request so the partner supplier can price accordingly.
Hidden Costs of New Pallets
New pallets carry costs that are easy to miss. Pallets from different suppliers or production runs can vary slightly in dimensions, which can matter for automated handling equipment.
Moisture is another factor. Pallets built from green lumber can shrink as they dry, loosening nails. In Colorado's dry climate, that drying can happen quickly.
Disposal rounds out the picture. Pallets used for one-way shipments still have to go somewhere at the receiving end, and paying to haul them off adds to the total cost.
Hidden Costs of Recycled Pallets
Recycled pallets have their own considerations. They may have mixed wood species, different board widths, and cosmetic wear. For most uses this is cosmetic, but for retail display it may matter.
Pallets that have not been heat-treated may not be acceptable for some shipments, such as exports. If you need heat-treated pallets, specify that and check the marks.
Quality varies between suppliers. Ask for samples, check deliveries against your specifications, and tell the supplier your load weights so they can recommend suitable pallets.
Environmental Externalities
Building a new pallet involves logging, sawmill work, hauling, and manufacturing, all of which use energy. Reusing a pallet avoids building a new one and skips most of those steps.
Producing new lumber also uses water and other resources that reuse largely avoids.
If your company reports on sustainability, use a recognized methodology for any emissions figures, and check current regulations and reporting requirements that apply to you.
Long-Term Savings and Bulk Pricing
Small per-pallet differences add up over months and years, especially for businesses that use pallets every day.
Recycled pallets are often less exposed to lumber price spikes than new pallets, which can make budgeting easier.
For pricing on your volumes, send a quote request through Pallet Colorado and we pass it to partner suppliers in our network.
Making the Right Choice for Your Business
The decision between new and recycled pallets is not either-or. Many businesses use new pallets for demanding jobs such as heavy loads, export shipments, or customer-facing displays, and recycled pallets for standard warehouse work and domestic distribution.
Start with your actual requirements. What loads will the pallets carry? How will they be handled? Where are they going? With those answers, a supplier can recommend a sensible mix.
Pallet Colorado connects you with partner suppliers who can quote recycled, new, or a mix of both, so you can decide based on the full cost and not just the sticker price.
About the Author
Pallet Colorado
Pallet Colorado is a referral service that connects Colorado businesses with partner pallet suppliers. We write practical guides on buying, selling, reusing and recycling pallets.
Request a Quote